did jacob really forget fantastical beast mean

Did jacob really forget fantastical beast mean movie#
Did jacob really forget fantastical beast mean update#

In New York at the time, it was forbidden for nomajes to marry wizards, lest they reveal the magical community. Why would Queenie erase Jacob's Memories?īecause she wants to marry him. Again seemingly it looks like its Queenie who erases the memories, no the rain. If you look closely, you'll see Queenie doing something with her wand, only after which Jacob loses his memories. If the rain would do it automatically, there would be no need for such an order. The President clearly orders Newt and Tina to obliviate Jacob's memories. Not until Queenie hugs and kisses him does he lose his memories. Furthermore, while they're standing outside in the rain (!) Jacob's memory is not yet erased. Even if you say the rain does not work underground, there was a point were they're standing under the glass - almost outdoors - and yet Jacob's memories are not yet erased. Thus, if the rain erased Jacob's memory, it would have happened immediately. The rain erases memories of all nomajes both indoors and outdoors, as can be clearly seen in the movie. Why do I believe Queenie erased the memories? Thus, I think some memories were retained as Queenie left behind those memories of her. I believe that Queenie erased Jacob's memories (!), not the rain. The neck being where the murtlap bit him. JACOB, quizzical and totally enchanted, touches his neck – a flicker of memory. They stare at each other – QUEENIE beams, radiant. JACOB looks up and is thunderstruck all over again: it’s QUEENIE. There is evidence to support this from the screenplay: Though here Jacob did not eat the Murtlap, its likely a bite provides similar resistance. Murtlaps eat crustaceans and the feet of anyone foolish Pickled and eaten, these Murtlap growths promote resistance toĬurses and jinxes, though an overdose may cause unsightly purpleĮar hair. It has a growth upon its back resembling a sea anemone. The Murtlap is a ratlike creature found in coastal areas of Britain.

Did jacob really forget fantastical beast mean movie#

Jacob did not lose all his memories because he was bitten by a Murtlap.Īnother answer that just occured to me after watching the movie again is that Jacob was resistant to the spell of the Sweeping Evil because he was previously bitten by a Murtlap: this angel over here, she filled me in on all the bad parts, and here we are, I guess, huh? I mean, don’t get me wrong, I had some weird ones. I mean, you said it, the potion only erases bad memories. NEWT: But you were supposed to have been Obliviated! This is confirmed in the dialogue for Fantastic Beasts 2 Scar in my neck?” Then it all comes flooding back when she’s smilingĪlison Sudol and Dan Fogler “Crimes of Grindelwald” Roundtable Interview The one thing where it’s like, “Where the hell did I get that crazy And he had his Titania, his dream girl, and then she walks It seeps into his art form with the muffins andĮverything. Just being like, “Hey?” It became familiar.

He may not remember the scary parts of it, but he definitely remembers being in the case. Thunderbird shower, the Obliviation spell… It erases bad memories andįelicia: Even the Erumpent was a good memory?ĭan: Even the Erumpent was a good memory, yes.Īlison: She was good. Up and he’s like, “I think I had a dream,” but he’s not sure? That’s Have you ever seen Midsummer Night’s Dream, where Bottom wakes Before that they were dreamlike.įelicia Grady: What parts from the first film did Queenie have to catch Jacob up on? Did Jacob remember the Erumpent incident?įelicia: Because he forgot all the bad memories.ĭan: Yeah, I think he remembered a lot of it.ĭan: Erumpent puffs, Niffler muffins… It’s like Midsummer Night’s Dream. Evidently his memories of the Wizarding world were confirmed by Queenie's presence.

Did jacob really forget fantastical beast mean update#

We also now have an update relating to Fantastic Beasts 2: The Crimes of Grindlewald. It comes flooding back to himĮXCLUSIVE: Dan Fogler Talks Queenie and Jacob and More in “Crimes of Grindelwald” at Comic-Con! ” No, I think you see at the end of the first one. So there’s not a period where he has to relearn everything.ĭan: Relearn everything! And he’s reading this scroll before…ĭan: “Ahh, okay, I’m back. It’s not explained exactly why, but he does have some recollection for sure, yeah.Īlison: Okay. So that actually brings us, though… If they’re having a complex relationship, does Jacob remember what happened last film? It’s kind of hinted at at the end, but it was never confirmed, so…ĭan: I think he does have… yeah. He smilesįantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them: The Original ScreenplayĪnd the actor seems pretty convinced that his memory was returned when he saw her.Īlison: It’s the best. Totally enchanted, touches his neck – a flicker of memory. Stare at each other – QUEENIE beams, radiant. He (sorta) remembered her, at least according to the film's official screenplay.